Guide
Should I repair or replace my furnace? The framework
Rich Jagisch
Director of Growth
10 minute read
11/17/2026
:quality(80))
If your furnace is less than 10 years old, repair it. If it's more than 15 years old and the repair will cost over $1,000, replace it. The same goes for a furnace on its third repair in two winters, or one with a cracked heat exchanger.
The hard cases fall in between. For those, our sales team uses a simple test: if the furnace is over 15 and you don't want to pay the repair quote, that reluctance is telling you something.
This guide walks through the decision by age and repair cost, then covers what a planned replacement costs in Colorado.
Key takeaways
Under 10 years old, repair it. Over 15, replace it if the repair tops $1,000, if it's the third repair in two winters, or if the heat exchanger is cracked.
Between 10 and 15 years, it depends on the repair and on the furnace's history.
The common rules of thumb are crude. Age and the number of repairs tell you more.
Count repairs as well as dollars. Three calls in two winters is a warning, even if each bill was small.
Decide while the furnace still runs. It's the only time you can compare quotes properly.
How old is too old to repair a furnace?
Past 15 years, for anything expensive.
:quality(80))
A gas furnace typically lasts 15 to 20 years [1]. A well-maintained one can reach 30 [2]. ENERGY STAR suggests considering replacement once a furnace is more than 15 years old [3]. The costly parts tend to fail in the second half of a furnace's life. They also tend to fail close together, because they've all run for the same number of hours.
That's why age tells you more than any single repair. Homeowners seem to know it. On calls, the furnace's age is often the first thing they mention. One caller described a furnace that was 17 years old, serviced every year and in great shape. Then came a "but."
That "but" matters. A 17-year-old furnace in great shape is still 17. It works today. The real question is whether it will work in February.
| Furnace age | Small repair, under $500 | Major repair, $500 to $1,500 | Big repair, over $1,500, or a cracked heat exchanger |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 10 years | Repair | Repair. Check the parts warranty first. | Repair if it's under warranty. If not, get a second opinion. |
| 10 to 15 years | Repair | Repair once, and start planning a replacement | Replace, unless the furnace has been trouble-free |
| Over 15 years | Repair, and start planning | Replace | Replace |
| Over 20 years | Repair only if you'll replace within the year | Replace | Replace |
Don't know how old yours is? The date is coded into the serial number, on a label inside the furnace cabinet. Search the brand name plus "serial number date" to decode it. For more on lifespan and warning signs, see how long does a furnace last?
:quality(80))
When should I repair my furnace?
When the part is cheap and the furnace is young.
Some parts wear out on every furnace. Igniters, flame sensors and thermostats are the usual ones. Replacing one costs $80 to $480 [4], and it says nothing about the furnace's future. A dead igniter on a 7-year-old furnace is a repair of $250 or less. Pay it.
Repair also makes sense when the part is still under warranty. Carrier, for one, covers furnace parts for 10 years if the furnace was registered within 90 days of installation, and for five years if it wasn't [5]. The manufacturer's warranty doesn't cover labor [5], so you'll still pay the technician. You keep a furnace with years left in it.
For prices by part, see furnace repair cost: what's normal, and what's a signal.
When should I replace my furnace?
Any one of these four is reason enough.
1. The furnace is over 15 and the repair costs more than $1,000. The four-figure repairs are a new heat exchanger and some blower and draft motor replacements [4] [6]. They come late in a furnace's life, and rarely alone. Spend $1,400 on a blower motor for an 18-year-old furnace and you have an 18-year-old furnace with a new blower motor. One homeowner told us this fall of a $9,000 repair quote. The alternative being weighed was a whole new system.
2. It's the third repair in two winters. Each one may have been reasonable. Three in a row are a pattern, and another is likely. ENERGY STAR lists frequent repairs among its signs that it's time to replace [3].
3. The heat exchanger is cracked. The heat exchanger keeps exhaust gases apart from the air you breathe. The Department of Energy lists checking it for cracks as a standard part of furnace maintenance [7], and federal safety officials warn that a furnace can produce carbon monoxide, which is odorless and deadly [8]. A technician who finds a crack will shut the furnace off. A new exchanger costs $1,000 to $3,000, against an average of $2,000 to $5,400 for a new furnace [4]. Check the warranty first, because some manufacturers cover the heat exchanger for 20 years [5]. We cover this case in cracked heat exchanger: repair or replace?
4. The house was never comfortable. Maybe the furnace has always started and stopped every few minutes. Maybe the upstairs has always been hot and the basement cold. No repair changes either one, because the furnace is the wrong size for the house. The Department of Energy notes that heating systems are often oversized [7]. See why is my furnace short cycling?
What if the repair quote falls in between?
Most real decisions do. Picture a 13-year-old furnace that needs a $900 motor. Or a 16-year-old furnace with two repairs behind it and a $600 control board ahead.
There are two common rules of thumb. The first is known as the $5,000 rule. Multiply the furnace's age by the repair cost. If the result tops $5,000, replacement is worth considering [9]. By that rule, a $600 repair on a 13-year-old furnace scores $7,800. The second comes from Angi, which suggests thinking about replacement once repairs approach 30 percent of the price of a new furnace, or roughly $1,500 to $2,000 [2].
Both are fine as a first pass. Neither knows anything about your furnace.
Our sales team uses a different test. If the furnace is over 15 and you don't want to pay the repair quote, replace it. The reluctance usually means you expect another bill soon. If you look at the quote and think it's fair for a furnace that's been reliable, pay it. Then plan the replacement for a season you choose.
Three questions help with the cases in between:
Will you be in the house in five years? If so, you'll get the use of a new system. If you plan to sell next year, a repair may be enough.
Is the air conditioner just as old? If it is, one heat pump can replace both. That's one project in place of two. If you'd rather keep a gas furnace as backup, a dual-fuel system pairs the two.
Do you want to compare quotes? You can do that only while the furnace still runs.
What does furnace replacement cost in Colorado?
We haven't found published replacement prices specific to Colorado. Nationally, a new gas furnace averages $2,000 to $5,400 installed [4]. Angi puts the average closer to $5,500 [2]. A heat pump that replaces both the furnace and the air conditioner costs more than a furnace alone.
Two things move the price here. The first is altitude. Most furnaces have to be adjusted downward by 4 percent for every 1,000 feet above 2,000 feet [10], so equipment has to be chosen with elevation in mind. The second is electrical work, which varies from house to house. A new dedicated circuit typically costs $570 to $1,000 [11]. Upgrading a 100-amp panel to 200 amps runs $1,500 to $3,000 [12].
Along the Front Range, our engineers usually replace an aging furnace with a cold-climate heat pump. It takes over from both the furnace and the air conditioner. Whether one can keep up with a Colorado cold snap is a fair question, and we answer it with field data in do heat pumps work in cold weather? It's sized from a calculation of what the house needs, the method building codes call for [13].
A complete quote lists the equipment by model number. It also lists the electrical work, the permit, removal of the old furnace and the warranty terms. ENERGY STAR advises homeowners to get exactly that in writing: costs, model numbers, schedule and warranty [14]. Ours come with a 10-year manufacturer parts warranty and a 1-year installation warranty.
To see every line a quote should have, read comparing HVAC quotes line by line.
What replacing won't do
It won't feel good to retire a furnace that still runs. One homeowner told us a technician had just praised the furnace's condition. Getting rid of something that works felt wrong. That's a fair instinct. But a 17-year-old furnace that works today may not work in February, and only one of those dates is up to you.
It won't be cheap or quick. A replacement costs thousands of dollars, and it puts a crew in your house for a day or two. That's the best reason to plan it for spring or fall.
It won't necessarily lower your energy bill. A heat pump runs on electricity, and gas costs less than electricity for the same amount of heat. A fair comparison covers a full year, old furnace and air conditioner against the new system. We lay it out in heat pump vs furnace. How we size a replacement is covered in what size heat pump do I need? It doesn't come out ahead in every house.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
Lennox, "How long does a furnace last?" https://www.lennox.com/residential/lennox-life/consumer/how-long-does-a-furnace-last
Angi, "How to know if you should repair or replace your furnace." https://www.angi.com/articles/when-should-i-replace-my-furnace.htm
ENERGY STAR, "When is it time to replace?" https://www.energystar.gov/saveathome/heating-cooling/replace
HomeGuide, "Furnace repair cost." https://homeguide.com/costs/furnace-repair-service-cost
Carrier, "Comfort 96 gas furnace," product page. https://www.carrier.com/us/en/residential/furnaces/59sc6.html
Angi, "How much does the average furnace repair cost?" by Paige Bennett, updated August 23, 2024. https://www.angi.com/articles/how-much-does-common-furnace-repair-cost.htm
U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver, "Furnaces and boilers." https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/furnaces-and-boilers
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, "Keep warm and safe this winter: tips for using generators, furnaces and space heaters," January 23, 2026. https://www.cpsc.gov/Newsroom/News-Releases/2026/Keep-Warm-and-Safe-This-Winter-Tips-for-Using-Generators-Furnaces-and-Space-Heaters
CBS News, "What is the $5,000 rule for HVAC systems?" by Angelica Leicht, June 24, 2026. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/what-is-5000-rule-hvac-systems/
ACHR News, "Furnaces must be modified for high-altitude applications," by Joanna R. Turpin, November 27, 2017. https://www.achrnews.com/articles/136057-furnaces-must-be-modified-for-high-altitude-applications
HomeAdvisor, "How much does it cost to install a dedicated circuit?" https://www.homeadvisor.com/cost/electrical/cost-to-install-a-dedicated-circuit
Inch Calculator, "Cost to upgrade an electrical panel," updated August 14, 2023. https://www.inchcalculator.com/electrical-panel-upgrade-cost-guide/
Air Conditioning Contractors of America, "Manual J residential load calculation." https://www.acca.org/Manual-J
ENERGY STAR, "10 tips for hiring a heating and cooling contractor." https://www.energystar.gov/saveathome/heating-cooling/10-tips-hiring
Replace before it breaks. If the repair quote on your furnace is one you don't want to pay, our engineers can design a replacement for your house from a scan you take with your phone. You'll see the full price within 24 hours. [See how it works](/how-it-works).